EV tax Credit Analysis - Consumer Reports

CoachTerry

Well-known member
First Name
Terry
Joined
Feb 10, 2023
Threads
20
Messages
63
Reaction score
84
Location
Chevy Chase, MD
Vehicles
Cybertruck
Occupation
Wellness Coach
Country flag
Electric Cars and Plug-In Hybrids That Qualify for Federal Tax Credits
Here’s how to find out which new and used EVs may qualify for a tax credit of up to $7,500 in 2023 and 2024
By Keith BarryUpdated September 22, 2023
Tesla Cybertruck EV tax Credit Analysis - Consumer Reports nlineHero-2023-Ford-F-150-Lightning-f-driving-7-23
Some versions of the Ford F-150 Lightning are eligible for a full $7,500 federal tax credit.Photo: Ford
The Treasury Department updated its list of which new electric cars may be eligible for a federal tax credit of up to $7,500. The credit depends on where EVs are made, where their battery components and minerals come from, how much they cost, and how much buyers earn. Those restrictions may not apply if an EV is leased instead of purchased.
The Chevrolet Bolt, Ford F-150 Lightning, and Tesla Model Y are among the 11 EVs eligible for a full $7,500 credit—and a base-model Bolt 1LT should cost just $19,995 after the tax credit and destination fee. After some significant MSRP discounts, more versions of the Ford F-150 Lightning now qualify, as does the Tesla Model X. The Tesla Model 3 Performance remains the only Consumer Reports recommended vehiclethat is eligible for a full credit.
Nine vehicles, including the Ford Mustang Mach-E and the least expensive version of the Tesla Model 3, will get only a partial credit of $3,750.
Add CR Magazine to Your Home
Get monthly delivery of our flagship magazine filled with home tips, product reviews, safety news, and more.
Upgrade to All Access
The changes are part of the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022. Designed to address climate change, healthcare, and taxes, the legislation also modifies how tax credits for certain new EVpurchases are calculated. The provisions of the act went into effect in phases. Vehicles must be manufactured in North America and have an MSRP below $80,000 for an SUV and $55,000 for a sedan, wagon, or hatchback.
more on EVs
Beginning April 18, the full tax credit was divided into two parts. To qualify for the first $3,750, at least 50 percent of a vehicle’s battery components must be produced or assembled in North America. To get the second $3,750, at least 40 percent of critical minerals used in the battery must be extracted or processed in the U.S. or in a country that is a U.S. free-trade agreement partner, or they must have been made from materials recycled in North America. These requirements will get stricter every year.
None of these regulations apply to leased EVs and PHEVs, so potential buyers interested in an electric car or plug-in hybrid that isn’t eligible for a tax credit may want to consider leasing instead of purchasing.
In this article, Consumer Reports has details on how to maximize your savings, including using tools such as our Electric Vehicle Savings Finderto see which cars qualify. We’ve tested versions of many of the models; click through the model names below for road tests and ratings. Others on the list are either EVs that aren’t on sale yet or plug-in hybrid versions that we haven’t purchased for evaluation but have experienced in most cases.
Ultimately, the tax credit may determine just how much money you’ll save by going electric. We will continue to update this article as more vehicles are added to the list.
Tesla Cybertruck EV tax Credit Analysis - Consumer Reports CR-Cars-InlineHero-2023-Nissan-Leaf-r-driving-8-22
The 2023 Nissan Leaf no longer qualifies for a federal EV tax credit.
Photo: Nissan
The IRS says the manufacturers of the following EVs and PHEVs indicated that they’re currently eligible for a full tax credit of $7,500 provided other requirements are met, such as vehicle MSRP and buyer income, which are explained in detail later in this article:
Many of these vehicles may also qualify for state and local incentives. You can find out more here, at CR’s EV incentive finder. Not all of these vehicles are currently on sale.
If a manufacturer uses different suppliers or assembly locations, some vehicles may qualify while others may not, even if they’re the same exact make and model. That’s the case for the Tesla Model 3, which qualifies for either a full or partial tax credit depending on how it’s equipped. Other vehicles may qualify in the future after automakers make changes to their battery and component suppliers, or if the U.S. signs free-trade agreements with more countries.
Tesla also added a disclaimer to its website warning buyers that although some vehicles may be eligible for a full $7,500 tax credit now, they may no longer be in 2024. “Reductions likely after Dec. 31,” it reads. Tesla did not respond to CR’s questions about why vehicle eligibility might change, but Chris Harto, CR’s senior policy analyst for transportation and energy, says that automakers might be anticipating provisions of the IRS that go into effect in 2024.
“They may be expecting further restrictions, and it sounds like they’re concerned that some of their vehicles will lose at least partial credit,” he says.

Which Cars May Qualify Only for a Partial EV Tax Credit?

The Treasury Department says the manufacturers of the following EVs and PHEVs indicated that they’re currently eligible for a partial tax credit of $3,750 if put into service on or after April 18, 2023, provided other requirements are met, such as vehicle MSRP and buyer income:
  • BMW X5 xDrive50e PHEV (2024 model year, MSRP $80,000 or below)
  • Ford Escape PHEV (2022 and 2023 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below; may qualify for a partial tax credit of $6,843 due to battery size if put into service before April 18, 2023)
  • Ford E-Transit (2022 and 2023 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below)
  • Ford Mustang Mach-E (2022 and 2023 model years, 2022 and 2023 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below)
  • Jeep Wrangler 4xe PHEV (2022, 2023, and 2024 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below)
  • Jeep Grand Cherokee 4xe PHEV (2022, 2023, and 2024 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below)
  • Lincoln Corsair Grand Touring PHEV (2022 and 2023 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below; may qualify for a partial tax credit of $6,843 due to battery size if put into service before April 18, 2023)
  • Rivian R1S (2023 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below)
  • Rivian R1T (2023 model years, MSRP $80,000 or below)
  • Tesla Model 3 Standard Range Rear-Wheel Drive only (2022 and 2023 model years, MSRP $55,000 or below)
These vehicles no longer appear on the Treasury Department’s list of vehicles that qualify for the tax credit, although they appeared on previous lists. If these vehicles were put into service before April 18, 2023, owners may still qualify for a tax credit:
  • Audi Q5 TFSI e Quattro PHEV
  • BMW 330e sedan (may have qualified for partial credit up to $5,836 due to battery size if made in North America)
  • BMW X5 xDrive45e SUV
  • Genesis GV70 Electrified SUV
  • Nissan Leaf
  • Volvo S60 PHEV (may have qualified for partial credit of $5,419 due to battery size), Extended Range, and T8 Recharge
Although the Volkswagen ID.4 wasn’t on the initial list, it now qualifies for a full tax credit. Nissan said it was unable to certify that the Leaf met new battery component and critical mineral requirements in time for the April 18 deadline. “We are working closely with our suppliers and are hopeful that Leaf will qualify for at least partial credit in the future,” a spokesperson for the automaker told CR.

How Do You Claim the EV Tax Credit?

According to the IRS, you must file Form 8936, “Qualified Plug-in Electric Drive Motor Vehicle Credit (Including Qualified Two-Wheeled Plug-in Electric Vehicles)” with your tax return. You will also need to provide your vehicle identification number (VIN), which can be found on the registration or on the dashboard at the base of the windshield.
Starting in 2024, the process will get easier. Buyers will be able to transfer their credit to a car dealership at the time of purchase, which will work sort of like an instant discount on the price of the vehicle.

What Is the Income Limit for the EV Tax Credit?

It’s not just the car—it’s also the buyer. To qualify for a new car tax credit, your household income must have an adjusted gross income of up to $300,000. If you’re filing as head of household, you must earn below $225,000, and individual filers will qualify only with income below $150,000. This provision may not apply if a vehicle is leased.
Tesla Cybertruck EV tax Credit Analysis - Consumer Reports ero-2024-Chevrolet-Equinox-EV-3LT-charge-door-3-23
The charge port on a Chevrolet Equinox EV.
Photo: Chevrolet

The Rules

In order to qualify for a tax credit of up to $7,500, a new EV or eligible plug-in hybrid vehicle (PHEV) must meet certain rules:
• A vehicle’s MSRP must not exceed certain limits, so pricey EVs, such as the GMC Hummer EV, Lucid Air, and Tesla Model S and Model X, won’t qualify. For SUVs, pickup trucks, and vans, the threshold is $80,000. For sedans, hatchbacks, wagons, and other vehicles, the credit cuts off at $55,000. These limits are based on a vehicle’s MSRP, not on its sale price, so a heavily discounted luxury car would not qualify. In addition, this requirement may not apply to some leased vehicles.
• Regardless of how a vehicle is advertised, whether it counts as an SUV, wagon, or hatchback is determined by the Environmental Protection Agency and listed on the window sticker. For example, the Ford Mustang Mach-Eis listed as a small SUV, but the Chevrolet Bolt EUV is classified as a small station wagon.
• A vehicle must be assembled in North America, including Canada and Mexico, to qualify for any tax credit. This eliminates credits for vehicles assembled elsewhere, including the BMW i4, Hyundai Ioniq 5, Kia EV6, and Toyota bZ4X. (This requirement also may not apply to some leased vehicles.) It doesn’t matter if a vehicle comes from an Asian or European brand, only where it’s assembled.
• To qualify for a full tax credit, at least 50 percent of a vehicle’s battery components must be produced or assembled in North America. In addition, at least 40 percent of critical minerals used in the battery must be extracted or processed in the U.S. or in a country that’s a U.S. free-trade agreement partner, or they must have been made from materials recycled in North America. The new rules will become stricter over time, with requirements increasing by 10 percent each year through 2027. By then, 90 percent of battery components and 80 percent of critical minerals will have to meet the guidelines.
• Car buyers must meet certain income guidelines. Households with an adjusted gross income up to $300,000 will still qualify for the new-car credit, while heads of household must earn below $225,000 and individual filers will qualify only with income below $150,000. This provision may not apply if a vehicle is leased.
• PHEVs with a battery of at least 7 kWh may qualify for a tax credit as long as they meet all of the other requirements. For PHEVs, the tax credit is calculated either as 15 percent of the vehicle’s MSRP, the dollar difference between the cost of the PHEV and a similarly equipped gas-powered version of the same vehicle, or $7,500—whichever is lowest.
• Starting on Dec. 31, 2023, vehicles with components from countries that have been designated “foreign entities of concern” will no longer be eligible for a tax credit. The list of countries with this designation has not yet been compiled.
• There’s no longer a 200,000 vehicle sales cap on tax credits that made EVs and plug-in hybrids from Tesla, GM, and Toyota ineligible under earlier rules. Previously, once an automaker sold more than 200,000 qualifying vehicles, the credit began to phase out.
Tesla Cybertruck EV tax Credit Analysis - Consumer Reports ineHero-EVGo-2022-Chevrolet-Bolt-EUV-charging-3-23
The 2023 Chevrolet Bolt EUV qualifies for the full $7,500 federal EV tax credit.
Photo: Chevrolet

Why Does the EV Tax Credit Keep Changing?

The Treasury Department says that the new rules are aimed at moving EV manufacturing and sourcing away from China and to the U.S. and its free-trade partners, which are Australia, Bahrain, Canada, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Israel, Jordan, South Korea, Mexico, Morocco, Nicaragua, Oman, Panama, Peru, and Singapore. They also now include Japan, after it entered into a special minerals-focused trade agreement with the U.S., signed just before the new rules were released, and may expand to include countries in the European Union as well, Reuters reports. A 2022 analysis of the EV supply chain from the International Energy Agency shows that a vast majority of minerals, components, and battery cells are currently from China.
Although directives about battery and mineral sourcing are meant to provide an incentive for manufacturing in the U.S., automakers and EV advocates have told Consumer Reports they’re concerned that the complexity of these rules may make it difficult for consumers to find a vehicle that qualifies for the credits or understand how much they’ll be eligible to claim.
CR’s Harto says it’s no surprise that fewer cars qualify for a credit. “The requirements were going to be difficult for automakers to meet immediately,” he says, “but we expect this list to grow quite a bit in the coming months and years as automakers now have clear targets to hit to become eligible, and are working hard to qualify.”
Buyers who are interested in the tax credit must do some research to see if the specific vehicle they’re considering qualifies. The IRS has a listof vehicle makes and models that automakers have certified as potentially qualifying for a credit, under penalty of perjury. There’s also a list at fueleconomy.gov.
CR’s EV Incentive Finder can also tell you whether the model you’re interested in may be eligible for a federal tax credit, as well as state and local incentives that might save you thousands more. GM launched a website where people interested in buying a new EV from GM can see how much of a tax credit—if any—it’s eligible for. And the White House says that Google plans to create a search tool for EV tax credit eligibility as well.
Things may get easier in 2024. That’s when qualified dealerships will be able to offer the tax credit directly to buyers at the point of sale, so buyers won’t have to wait to claim the credit on their taxes. Until that provision goes into effect, buyers who don’t have a tax liability may be able to benefit from the tax credit on a lease.

What If You Ordered a Car Before April 2023?

Cars that were ordered and paid for earlier this year or in 2022 but weren’t delivered by April 18, 2023, will be subject to the new regulations on battery and critical mineral content. A White House spokesperson told CR that a car buyer would have to take possession of their vehicle before April 18, 2023, to qualify for the tax credits under the old rules.

Do Leased EVs Qualify for a Full Tax Credit?

There’s some good news if the car you want to purchase doesn’t qualify for a tax credit. A Treasury spokesperson told CR that most traditional leases would qualify for a $7,500 commercial credit that’s not subject to the myriad requirements that must be met to qualify for the consumer new-vehicle credit.
Here’s how it works: In the case of a lease, the dealer would receive the commercial credit, not the person leasing the vehicle, and it would be up to the dealer to pass those savings on to the consumer, potentially by lowering the vehicle’s purchase price. If a dealer does pass the savings along, drivers could get a tax credit on a car made outside North America, such as the popular Hyundai Ioniq 5. High-income consumers and those who lease a high-cost EV, such as a Lucid Air or Tesla Model S or X, would also be able to enjoy the $7,500 credit as long as the dealer passes those savings along.
If a buyer chooses to do this, however, they should make sure to double-check the dealership’s math. “Make sure to ask for an itemized bill of sale that shows where the tax credit has been applied,” says Gabe Shenhar, associate director of CR’s Auto Test Center. “And make sure the dealership doesn’t mark up the price of the car accordingly.”
Some automakers, including Hyundai, Lucid, and Polestar, already factor a full $7,500 tax credit into the lease deals listed on their websites. Learn more about leasing here.

Do Used EVs Qualify for a Tax Credit?

For the first time, buyers of used EVs will get a tax credit, either $4,000 or 30 percent of the sale price of the vehicle, whichever is lower. But that’s only if they buy a car from a dealership, and only if the vehicle wasn’t previously resold after Aug. 16, 2022. In other words, a one-owner used car sold at an authorized dealership may be eligible for a tax credit, but a two-owner car won’t be. Neither will a one-owner car sold privately.
The income threshold is lower for used EV buyers: $150,000 for joint filers, $112,500 for a head of household, and $75,000 for an individual. But the rules about where the car was made or where the battery comes from don’t apply to used vehicles.

Which Cars May Qualify Only for the New EV Tax Credit If Leased?

In addition to the nine vehicles listed above that lost out on a tax credit starting April 18, 2023, because of battery and critical mineral requirements, these current and coming EVs (and two fuel-cell vehicles) aren’t made in North America, so they probably won’t qualify for a tax credit if they’re purchased. But that might change in the future if their assembly location changes. In addition, dealers may pass a tax credit on to consumers if the vehicle is leased instead of purchased.
Regardless of where they’re assembled, these vehicles have an MSRP that’s too high and won’t qualify for any tax credit if they’re purchased, although dealers may pass a tax credit on to consumers if the vehicle is leased:

Making Sense of EV Tax Credits

Keith Barry
Keith Barry has been an auto reporter at Consumer Reports since 2018. He focuses on safety, technology, and the environmental impact of cars. Previously, he led home and appliance coverage at Reviewed; reported on cars for USA Today, Wired, and Car & Driver; and wrote for other publications as well. Keith earned a master’s degree in public health from Tufts University. Follow him on Twitter @itskeithbarry.
Sponsored

 

SlegMD

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 24, 2023
Threads
0
Messages
591
Reaction score
1,056
Location
Arizona
Vehicles
Lexus
Occupation
Physical therapy
Country flag
Too much Gov’ment in my CT…. As per usual.

Edit: Honestly though, this process should be more black and white.
Purchase certain EV: ☑
Within price margin: ☑
Apply to point of purchase: ☑

Thank you for your purchase.
 
Last edited:

MonkeyDeLuffy

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 7, 2023
Threads
3
Messages
230
Reaction score
363
Location
BayArea
Vehicles
Maverick
Occupation
Math In-and-Out
Country flag
Tax credit is a joke for people live in silicon valley.
 

Gurule92

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 2, 2021
Threads
160
Messages
3,392
Reaction score
6,780
Location
Colorado Springs
Vehicles
MYP
Occupation
"Cyber" stuff
Country flag
I love how they just say CT is too expensive, but when you click their link for CT it shows max 69k lol
 


OP
OP

CoachTerry

Well-known member
First Name
Terry
Joined
Feb 10, 2023
Threads
20
Messages
63
Reaction score
84
Location
Chevy Chase, MD
Vehicles
Cybertruck
Occupation
Wellness Coach
Country flag
 




Top