HaulingAss
Well-known member
- Joined
- Oct 3, 2020
- Threads
- 28
- Messages
- 10,298
- Reaction score
- 20,703
- Location
- Western Washington, USA
- Vehicles
- Cybertruck DM, 2010 F-150, 2018 Performance Model 3, 2024 Performance Model 3
Good job trying to quantify the aero hit of mirrors! I haven't checked your measurements for frontal area but, if they are in the ballpark, that implies a 3% increase in aero drag due to the increase in frontal area alone. That's without considering the hit due to the lowering of the Cd due to the turbulent air created by mirrors, so the actual increase in drag would be considerably higher.You're right, getting an accurate measure of the efficiency gain by removing the mirrors would require a controlled test, like two identical CTs, one with and one without mirrors driving together for a 100 miles. I'll leave that to Kyle Connor.
As you know, drag is proportional to the CD and the frontal cross sectional area of the vehicle . I estimate the combined cross sectional area of the mirrors at about 1 sqft. The cross sectional area of the Cybertruck has not been officially disclosed, but a rough measurement gives about 31 sq ft. Based on these numbers, I should expect a drag reduction of (30 x .382 - 31 x .387) / 31 x .387 = (11.46 - 11.997) / 11.997 = - 0.0447 x 100 = -4.47%. That's not an insignificant improvement in efficiency. Others have estimated 3%. I'm expecting to see a range improvement of somewhere between 9 and 14 miles on a full to empty charge.
Is such a small improvement in range worth removing the mirrors? I pretty sure that Tesla engineers would say yes, and they would have if not for NHTSA.
The Cd's measured in small wind tunnels cannot be taken seriously due to the fact that you need a really large, very expensive tunnel to accurately measure a car or truck, and the first inaccuracies due to vehicle size are going to be on the drag differences between mirrors/no mirrors (since the mirror drag can get lost in the turbulent air created by the wind tunnel itself).
In other words, the aero advantages of mirror delete would be under-estimated in anything but a full-sized wind tunnel specifically designed to accurately measure drag of cars and trucks. That said, I'm not arguing that people should necessarily remove their mirrors, even in states in which it is currently legal to do so. As much as I appreciate efficiency, I don't have a range problem, and even 15 more miles of highway range isn't going to change the way I use the truck. I just don't like to see people claiming that mirrors don't cause much hit to range, it flies against the actual facts.
Elon Musk knows this, which is why he's chomping at the bit for the legalization of camera-based mirrors. Plus, his views on this are certainly reinforced by imminent autonomy.
Sponsored